Warp drives! Nothing’s gonna stop us now?

Starships. The idea captures the imagination, doesn’t it? But special relativity is a harsh law to live by if we, as a species, ever plan to make it beyond the constraints of our own solar system. It imposes the ultimate speed limit on the Universe. The speed of light. Nothing can travel faster than light. The only thing which can, in fact, travel at the speed of light is light itself. Aside from the fact that this would have made Star Wars significantly less exciting, this poses a problem. Is it even possible to travel to other stars within a single human lifetime?

The idea of a real life warp drive has been floated before, though it was found to require so much energy that even attempting it would be insane. As I recall, the fuel requirement was approximately what you’d obtain if you were to take three planet Jupiters and convert them to energy. Obviously, an engine more powerful than you could possibly imagine wouldn’t exactly be feasible as a technology.

But a recent study has breathed a new hope into the idea of a warp drive. Essentially, by modifying the ship’s design and how it would work (and I haven’t read the paper, so I don’t know the specifics here), such a warp drive could require dramatically less energy than previously thought, making it the fastest hunk of junk in the galaxy. And it would end up looking a bit like an olive suspended inside a bangle, apparently. Such a ship could be powered by a source about the size of a craft like Voyager I, and oscillating the intensity of the warp could reduce the power required even more – the same way in which pulsed lasers achieve a higher effective energy output from the same power source. I’m getting ahead of myself here. Allow me to explain the background…

As it happens, it’s all about how you interpret the laws set out by special relativity. Nothing can travel through spacetime faster than light. Not unless you believe those lying neutrinos. But it gets interesting when you realise that there’s nothing to stop spacetime itself from travelling faster than light. This might sound ridiculous at first, but it’s perfectly valid (and also, to directly quote Richard Obousy, president of Icarus Interstellar, “really cool”). For instance, in the colossal gravitational fields of black holes, spacetime itself can become warped. The spacetime around a rotating black hole actually gets pulled around like a ballerina’s skirt. Known as reference frame dragging, this is why objects orbiting black holes can appear to travel faster than light. From our perspective, they are travelling faster than light – but they aren’t travelling faster than light relative to their own frame of reference. That last statement is the key here. Enter Mexican physicist Miguel Alcubierre.

Alcubierre realised that if you were to literally warp spacetime, contracting it in front of you and expanding it behind you, it may enable you to travel faster than light in a region of perfectly flat spacetime. Anyone who’s watched Star Trek may be entertained by the fact that this has actually been termed a “warp bubble”. This would enable someone travelling in such a warp bubble to experience none of the bizarre relativistic effects (such as time dilation) that they might otherwise experience travelling at ludicrous speeds. Relative to the space around you, you’re not even travelling at all. It’s the space itself which is travelling, and it’s carrying you with it. Effectively, you’re creating a wave in spacetime and riding it like an interstellar surfer. Mind you, some mind melting consequences would still be possible while using such a mode of transport – see my Astrotropes: Faster Than Light article for more about that!

So could it be possible to actually warp spacetime? Well, Harold “Sonny” White at NASA’s Johnson Space Centre is actually conducting laboratory experiments to test the idea. With a sci-fi sounding device called the White-Juday Warp Field Interferometer, he and his colleagues are looking at the possibility of creating microscopically small spacetime warps (in a way which sounds not dissimilar to attempts made to detect gravitational waves). Currently they’re only trying to perturb spacetime by one part in 10 million and then trying to sense the disturbance. Baby steps. If it works though, it will be encouraging. Maybe we really could travel across the vast voids of interstellar space after all. If nothing else, in the meantime, it would speed up travelling around our own solar system dramatically.

From comments I’ve already seen, it would seem that some do not share my optimistic appraisal of the situation. It seems inevitable that there are going to be more naysayers talking about how we should all “stop daydreaming” and people willing to give thousands of reasons why not. I find their lack of faith disturbing.  You could, after all, come up with reasons not to do practically anything. It wasn’t actually that long ago that people gave reasons why aeroplanes would never work, and claimed that building a train to travel faster than 20 miles per hour would be instantly fatal to any passengers. Needless to say, trains and planes are now so commonplace that we don’t even question them anymore. So why not warp drives too? Why not indeed.

★ I have my suspicions that some people who work for CrossCountry Trains might still believe this to be true.

(And yes, the title of this post is a reference to ’80s pop music. What of it?),

About Invader Xan

Molecular astrophysicist, usually found writing frenziedly, staring at the sky, or drinking mojitos.
This entry was posted in physics, Sci Fi, space, Tech and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

10 Responses to Warp drives! Nothing’s gonna stop us now?



  3. Pingback: Mais-rápido-que-a-luz/Renderizando um sonho « O destruidor de mundos

  4. Pingback: Second star to the right, and straight on till morning… | Supernova Condensate

  5. Naufal says:

    I think I have known this idea from somewhere, I don’t know. It sounds interesting, although I don’t understand how it works hehe.

    Should the vessel has tyre-like design?

    • invaderxan says:

      It’s quite an old idea, actually. Just an old idea which has received a lot more attention in the past few years.

      And tyre-like, yes. Though I’ll be honest – I’m not sure specifically why this is the case…

  6. wavicle says:

    Somehow, I don’t think the warp drive implies that the we are off the hook in relativistic terms. I am only familiar with undergraduate special relativity, where all observers are intertial, and I have no intuition for anything else. Are there any theoretical papers out there on this topic? And any astrophysicists who are willing to translate for an experimental atomic physicist??

    • invaderxan says:

      Actually, by my understanding, for the hypothesis to work, it isn’t relativity that’s the problem. Effectively, this is dealing with inertial reference frames, because any starship equipped with a warp drive wouldn’t technically be accelerating. Instead, it’s the frame itself which is moving, with the observers being inertial within it. If that makes sense…?

      The problems are actually on the quantum side of things, so you may be more in your element. I’m afraid the specifics are on the edges of my knowledge, but the trouble is with quantum effects causing erroneous results in stress-energy tensors, such as negative mass-energy. There are a fair few papers around though. You may be interested in Alcubierre’s original paper, and if you have access to it, there’s a conference paper which provides quite an interesting discussion.

      Like I say, this isn’t exactly my area either, but essentially, as long as everything is possible within quantum field theory, it works out perfectly well without violating either special or general relativity…

  7. Glyn Jones says:

    Does the warp bubble deflect stuff? I wouldn’t want to hit something at light-speed.

    • invaderxan says:

      Very good question, and one I don’t know the answer to. I wouldn’t want to hit something while travelling faster than light either – seeing as even an atom or molecule could be hazardous at that kind of speed!

      I suppose, if a warp bubble didn’t deflect things, then some other means of doing so would have to be invented before warp travel would be possible. After all, space is full of stuff

Comments are closed.